By Timothy Loftus, Editor & Publisher | Sergeant Bluff Advocate
(SBA) - An acre of fertile farmland deserves more consideration than a square on a developer’s map. Yet when a large industrial proposal arrives, discussion often begins with the investment figure, the promised jobs and the projected tax revenue. Before long, a field that has produced crops for generations becomes a construction site. We are told to celebrate the opportunity. I believe we should first understand what we are giving up.
Across Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota and neighboring states, open country can look like an attractive alternative to crowded coastal metropolitan areas. From a developer’s perspective, assembling a large site near highways like I-29, utilities and resources may seem easier here than in places where development already presses against development. Add financial incentives, and the appeal grows. But the assumption that we have plenty of room deserves scrutiny. The Midwest’s open spaces are working spaces. A cornfield or soybean field is already doing something valuable, even when its contribution receives less attention than a groundbreaking ceremony.
American Farmland Trust reported that approximately 11 million acres of farmland and ranchland were converted to urban, highly developed or low-density residential uses between 2001 and 2016. That figure includes housing and other development, not just industry, but it illustrates how individual land decisions accumulate. One acre disappearing does not threaten America’s food supply overnight. Thousands of decisions repeated across decades, however, reduce the land available to produce food, feed and agricultural products.
Once productive farmland is graded, covered with concrete and crossed by underground infrastructure, returning it to farming can be extremely difficult and very expensive. A company can replace equipment or move operations. A community can’t simply order another stretch of fertile ground. Losing farmland also reaches beyond the person selling it. Farm suppliers, grain handlers, equipment dealers and other businesses depend on an agricultural economy like Woodbury County that needs land to function. When we calculate an industrial project’s benefits, we should also calculate the productive activity displaced by its arrival.
There’s a change in the landscape that financial projections rarely capture. Fields give way to enormous buildings, security fences, loading docks and illuminated parking lots. Depending on the operation, trucks, employee traffic, machinery or continuous lighting can reshape daily life for nearby residents. Roads built for a quieter community may require widening and repaving. That familiar drive through open country becomes a trip through an highly trafficked industrial corridor. For someone who chose rural life because of its quiet and slower pace, that transformation can feel like losing part of home while still living at the same address.
People in Sergeant Bluff, Salix and surrounding communities have an identity of their own. Residents who raise families, farm and run businesses here deserve a say in how their surroundings change. They’ll live with the traffic, noise and lights long after the construction crews leave.
A responsible employer can provide dependable wages, opportunities for young adults and business for local contractors and stores. New revenue can help support public services. Agriculture itself relies on processing, transportation and manufacturing. The question is whether a particular project offers lasting value on terms the community can afford.
Companies weigh costs and returns. Residents want a living wage, a home they can afford and a community where their children can stay or want to return too. If a developer sees our region chiefly as a source of inexpensive labor, available resources and generous tax incentives, local leaders need to recognize the imbalance. People deserve to be valued as neighbors and skilled workers, rather than treated as another expense to minimize.
The danger becomes clearest when financial conditions change. Tyson Foods’ closure of its Perry, Iowa, pork plant in June 2024 affected approximately 1,200 workers. Iowa State University Extension examined how the closure would reach beyond the plant through suppliers, household spending and local tax revenue. Years of employment can make a town dependent on paychecks it has no power to guarantee.
A company may decide that closing a location makes financial sense. The people left behind still have mortgages, utility bills and children in school. Local businesses lose customers. Families may face longer commutes or a move. A town can spend years trying to replace the employment that vanished with one corporate decision. When a community has expanded infrastructure or made financial commitments around that employer, the consequences can become harder to manage. The company can move on long before the town does.
Cheap labor, abundant resources and tax breaks may improve corporate margins without building a durable local economy. Communities need a plan for a possible closure before approving the project, while they still have the power to negotiate.
That’s why incentives require more scrutiny than applause. What will the community actually receive after exemptions, rebates and public expenses are considered? How many permanent jobs will exist, at what wages, and for how long? Who pays for expanded roads, water systems and emergency services? What happens if promised employment fails to materialize or operations end early? Communities should seek enforceable commitments, repayment provisions where appropriate and financial protection against abandonment. A promise at a public meeting should never carry more weight than the agreement officials ultimately sign.
Sergeant Bluff’s former MCI call center shows what it can take to put a vacant building back to work. Convergys closed the call center in 2018, affecting 178 employees, and the building sat vacant for years. An indoor sports complex was proposed in 2023, but that plan gave way to a different use. By November 2025, R. Perry Construction had made the larger of the two buildings its headquarters, alongside space for warehousing and distribution. That month, the City Council approved a development agreement with S.C. Developers, LLC, providing for rebates from new property tax revenue and setting a minimum assessed value of $5 million for that portion of the property. It took years, but an eyesore became a place of business again without paving another field.
Before asking to rezone a working field, a company should have to show why an existing industrial site won’t work. Here in Sergeant Bluff, the city lists about 117 acres along Dogwood Trail at its industrial park beside Interstate 29. The state-certified site is zoned for light industry and manufacturing, with access to water, sanitary sewer, electricity and natural gas.
Elsewhere in Woodbury County, Southbridge Business Park offers another place to look. The park, owned by Sioux City, sits south of Sioux Gateway Airport and has access to Union Pacific rail service. Its February 2025 certification report identified about 272 developable acres available at the time. The same report shows that some of that ground had been leased for farming. That distinction matters: an industrial designation doesn’t tell us whether we’re saving farmland. Start with vacant buildings and previously developed lots. Then compare sites already set aside for industry, including what each would take out of production. Residents deserve to see that comparison before officials vote on a rezoning request. If an existing site can do the job with less loss of productive soil, why open up another field?
Looking before we leap is an obligation to the people already here and those who will follow. Fertile ground, dependable livelihoods and peaceful communities deserve better than a hurried bargain. Before we exchange them for projected dollars, we need confidence that the benefits will last.